911EDA PCB Design Services Logo

Frequent Causes of PCB Failure by Poor PCB Design

Exploring Common PCB Design Mistakes: A Comprehensive Guide

In our rapidly advancing world, technology is deeply ingrained in everyday life. As new electronic products emerge and older technologies evolve, Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs) are integral components. However, the complexity of technologies packed into smaller footprints presents challenges that can lead to manufacturability problems when not addressed through careful PCB design. This comprehensive guide delves into common PCB design mistakes, shedding light on errors that compromise functionality, reliability, and cost-effectiveness.

Component Failure: Understanding the Core Issues

One of the most frequent causes of PCB failure is component issues. Below are some critical component-related mistakes that designers and engineers need to be vigilant about:

Illustration of Incorrect Component Footprints Leading to Alignment and Soldering Issues
  • Incorrect Component Footprints

    When component footprints are inaccurately designed, alignment and soldering issues can arise, leading to functionality breakdown. Learn how our PCB design services ensure accurate component footprints.

PCB Layout with Close Component Placement Leading to Solder Bridging
  • Poor Component Placement

  • Placing components too closely together can cause solder bridging, resulting in short circuits and performance degradation. In PCB design, the arrangement of components on the board’s surface is a critical aspect that directly affects the overall functionality and reliability of the electronic device. Component placement refers to the strategic positioning of components, such as integrated circuits (ICs), resistors, capacitors, and connectors on the PCB. When components are placed too closely together, several issues can arise, most notably solder bridging, which can have significant implications for the PCB’s performance:
    • Solder Bridging: Solder bridging occurs when the solder connecting adjacent pads of components melts during the soldering process and forms an unintended connection or bridge between the two pads. This connection can create a short circuit, allowing current to flow where it shouldn’t and potentially causing malfunction or damage to the circuit. Solder bridging often leads to erratic behavior, incorrect functionality, or complete failure of the device.
    • Short Circuits: Solder bridging essentially creates a conductive pathway between components that should be isolated. This can disrupt the intended flow of signals and power, leading to short circuits. Short circuits can cause overheating, increased power consumption, and even permanent damage to components, further reducing the device’s lifespan.
  • To prevent these issues, PCB designers need to carefully plan component placement by considering factors such as:

    • Minimum Clearance: Each component has specific requirements for minimum clearance, which ensures enough space between components to prevent solder bridging. Design guidelines provided by component manufacturers and industry standards are crucial in determining these clearances.
    • Thermal Considerations: Components generate heat during operation, and placing them too closely together can lead to heat buildup. Adequate spacing helps dissipate heat and prevent thermal issues that could affect the device’s performance and lifespan.
    • Signal Integrity: Components placed too closely together might interfere with signal paths, leading to cross-talk and electromagnetic interference. Proper spacing maintains signal integrity and reduces the risk of signal-related problems.

    • Performance Degradation: Even if a solder bridge doesn’t lead to an immediate short circuit, it can still impact the circuit’s performance. Unintended connections can interfere with signal paths, affecting the integrity of the signals and leading to data errors or reduced signal quality. This degradation can compromise the device’s overall performance, leading to inaccurate readings, slower response times, or reduced data transfer rates.
    • Reliability Issues: PCBs are often used in applications where reliability is paramount, such as aerospace, medical devices, or industrial control systems. Solder bridging increases the likelihood of unexpected failures, which can be disastrous in critical applications. Ensuring proper component spacing is essential for maintaining the reliability and longevity of the device.
Thermal Relief Pads on PCB for Proper Soldering
  • Neglecting Thermal Relief

    Inadequate use of thermal relief pads can hinder proper soldering, making the assembly process challenging and error-prone.

  • Heat Management Oversights

    Locating heat-generating components near the board’s edges can result in heat buildup, impairing overall system performance.

  • Misalignment of Surface Mount Devices (SMDs)

    Improper orientation of SMDs relative to the direction of wave soldering can result in shorts or open connections, sabotaging PCB functionality.

Routing Faux Pas: Ensuring Proper Traces and Connections

Routing is a critical phase in PCB design, and errors in this phase can lead to catastrophes. Here are prevalent routing-related mistakes that can compromise your design:

Traces Positioned Too Closely Causing Unintended Connections
  • Inaccurate Trace Widths

    Incorrect trace widths can lead to heat buildup, affecting overall system reliability. Ensuring proper trace width adherence is vital.

    In a printed circuit board (PCB), traces are the conductive pathways that carry electrical signals between components. The width of these traces, commonly called trace width or trace thickness, plays a significant role in determining how effectively electrical current can flow through them. The choice of trace width has implications for a PCB design’s electrical and thermal aspects.

    Electrical Considerations:

    The width of a trace affects its electrical resistance. Narrower traces have higher resistance, which can lead to voltage drops and signal degradation. Conversely, wider traces have lower resistance and provide a smoother path for the current to flow. Maintaining appropriate trace widths is crucial to ensure the proper functioning of the circuit and to prevent electrical issues such as:

    • Voltage Drop: Voltage drop occurs when current flows through a trace with higher resistance. This can lead to a discrepancy between the voltage supplied and the voltage received by the component, potentially affecting its performance or causing it to malfunction.
    • Signal Attenuation: Narrow traces can introduce signal attenuation, especially for high-frequency signals. This attenuation reduces the signal’s amplitude and quality, leading to data errors or unreliable communication between components.
    • Thermal Considerations:

      Apart from their electrical characteristics, traces also play a role in dissipating heat generated by components on the PCB. Components such as ICs, power regulators, and other active devices produce heat during operation. If traces are too narrow to carry away this heat efficiently, it can lead to localized heat buildup, which has several negative consequences:

    • Overheating Components: Insufficiently sized traces may struggle to dissipate the heat generated by components, causing them to heat up beyond acceptable limits. Overheated components can experience reduced performance, accelerated wear, and premature failure.
    • Thermal Stress: Inadequate heat dissipation can lead to thermal stress in the PCB material, causing expansion and contraction. This can result in mechanical pressure on solder joints, components, and the PCB itself, potentially leading to solder joint cracks, delamination, and other reliability issues.
    • Temperature-Dependent Behavior: Many electronic components exhibit different behaviors at varying temperatures. If heat buildup causes localized hotspots on the PCB, components operating within those areas may behave unpredictably or exhibit reduced lifespans.
    • Ensuring Proper Trace Width Adherence:

      Adhering to trace width guidelines is vital to avoid these issues and maintain a reliable and efficient PCB design. Designers consider various factors when determining trace width, including the current-carrying capacity of the trace, the required electrical performance, and the desired thermal management.

      Industry standards, design guidelines provided by PCB software tools, and component datasheets offer valuable insights into appropriate trace widths for different current levels and applications. Designers should also consider the layer stackup, copper weight, and overall thermal strategy when deciding on trace widths.
  • Proximity-Induced Connections

    Traces positioned too closely to each other without appropriate insulation can lead to unintended connections, short circuits, and system instability. Learn about our PCB design solutions for optimized trace layouts.

Right-Angle Traces with Insufficient Clearance Leading to Shorts
  • Right Angle Traces Dilemma

    Using right-angle traces with insufficient clearance near the board’s edges can result in shorts, hindering signal integrity and causing performance issues.

  • Suboptimal Routing Strategies

    Inefficient routing strategies may lead to connectivity issues, signal interference, and non-compliance with design specifications.

Preventing Common PCB Design Mistakes: Insights and Solutions

To ensure a successful PCB design, taking proactive steps and learning from past mistakes is crucial. Here’s how you can avoid the common pitfalls:

  • Embrace Design for Manufacturability (DFM)

  • Thermal Management Strategies

    • Implement strategic thermal management techniques to prevent heat-related issues and enhance overall system performance.
  • Trace Width Calculations

    • Ensure accurate trace width calculations based on current loads and material properties to prevent overheating and electrical failures.
  • Comprehensive Testing

    • Perform thorough testing at various design stages to identify and rectify potential issues before they translate into failures during production.

Addressing Soldering Issues in PCB Design

Soldering problems can be mitigated through careful design and manufacturing considerations:

  • Correct Footprint Design

    Ensure accurate component footprints to prevent misalignment and soldering defects during assembly.

    Component footprints in PCB design refer to the precise layouts and dimensions that depict where and how each electronic component will be soldered onto the PCB. These footprints provide crucial information to the PCB designer and the manufacturer about correctly placing, aligning, and soldering components onto the board during assembly.

    Importance of Accurate Component Footprints:

    • Proper Alignment: Accurate footprints ensure that components are aligned correctly with the designated solder pads and copper traces on the PCB. Misalignment can lead to electrical connectivity issues, mechanical stress on parts, and difficulty fitting the PCB into its intended enclosure.
    • Soldering Quality: Accurate footprints help ensure that solder joints form correctly between the component leads and the PCB pads. When the alignment is correct, the solder can flow evenly, creating robust and reliable solder joints. Misaligned parts can result in solder bridges, cold solder joints, or incomplete solder connections, which can cause electrical discontinuities and reduce the reliability of the PCB.
  • Best Practices for Ensuring Accurate Footprints:

    • Consult Datasheets: Component datasheets often include recommended footprint dimensions and layouts. Designers should refer to these datasheets to ensure the footprints match the manufacturer’s recommendations.
    • Use Design Software Libraries: Most PCB design software includes libraries of pre-defined component footprints. Using these libraries helps ensure the footprints are accurate and compatible with industry standards.
    • Double-Check Dimensions: Designers should verify the dimensions of each pad, lead, and mounting hole in the footprint against the component’s datasheet. Minor discrepancies can lead to significant alignment issues during assembly.
    • Perform Test Fits: Before finalizing the design, performing Test fits using prototypes or simulation tools is a good practice. This helps identify potential alignment or soldering issues early in the design phase.
    • Preventing Shorts and Opens: Misaligned or incorrect footprints can lead to solder bridges between adjacent pads or open connections where no solder joint forms. Both situations can cause shorts or opens in the circuit, leading to functional failures or intermittent behavior.
    • Ease of Manufacturing: Manufacturers use accurate component footprints as a reference during the assembly process. When footprints are precise, manufacturers can automate the assembly process more effectively, reducing the risk of errors and minimizing the need for manual adjustments.
  • Thermal Relief Pads

    Implement thermal relief pads for components with large ground connections to facilitate proper soldering and avoid connectivity issues.

  • Optimal Solder Mask Application

    Apply solder mask with precision to prevent solder bridges and ensure proper component isolation.

    Reflow Soldering Considerations

    Understand reflow soldering profiles and component compatibility to prevent overheating and ensure reliable solder joints.

Fixing PCB Failures: A Collaborative Endeavor

In the unfortunate event of a PCB failure, swift action is imperative. Here’s how 911EDA can help:

  • Thorough Testing: We perform comprehensive tests to identify the root cause of failures.
  • Design Review: Our experts analyze your design to pinpoint design flaws contributing to the failure.
  • Precision Corrections: Once we determine the problem, our engineers and designers can make the necessary changes so your board will function as expected.

Connect with Us

If you face issues like these, tell us about your PCB failures, and we will contact you to discuss them.

Got Questions? Our FAQs Have Answers

Curious about the nitty-gritty of PCB design services? You can explore our frequently asked questions section to find answers to common queries. From design strategies to turnaround times, our FAQs provide insights into what sets 911EDA’s services apart.

Conclusion: Navigating the Design Landscape

In the intricate world of PCB design, the path to success is lined with awareness and continuous improvement. Steering clear of common PCB design mistakes empowers engineers and designers to create robust, efficient, and reliable electronic products that define our technological landscape.

Remember, understanding the nuances of PCB design is an ongoing journey, and by avoiding these pitfalls, you’re one step closer to achieving excellence in your creations.

Frequent Causes of PCB Failure by Poor PCB Design
Article Name
Frequent Causes of PCB Failure by Poor PCB Design
Uncover vital insights into avoiding common PCB design mistakes that compromise functionality and reliability for successful electronic product creation.
Publisher Name
Publisher Logo

911EDA PCB Design Services Logo
  • 2131 Palomar Airport Rd., Ste. 239
    Carlsbad, CA 92011
  • (800) 320-2480
  • sales@911eda.com

Key Concepts

© 2007-2023 911EDA, Inc.