Causes of PCB Failure: Pitfalls in Design and Solutions

Here are 8 frequent causes of PCB failure to be aware of:

• Unfinished or incorrect design documents.
• Unsuitable base materials.
• Incorrect trace dimensions.
• Inadequate spacing between traces.
• Issues with acid entrapments.
• Insufficient distance between trace and edge.
• Errors in the drilling procedure.
• Issues with annular ring integrity.

Exploring Common Causes of PCB Failure

In our rapidly advancing world, technology is deeply ingrained in everyday life. As new electronic products emerge and older technologies evolve, Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs) are integral components. However, the complexity of technologies packed into smaller footprints presents challenges that can lead to manufacturability problems when not addressed through careful PCB design. This comprehensive guide delves into common PCB design mistakes, shedding light on errors that compromise functionality, reliability, and cost-effectiveness.

Component Failure: Understanding the Core Issues

One of the most frequent causes of PCB failure is component issues. Below are some critical component-related mistakes that designers and engineers need to be vigilant about:

Incorrect Component Footprints

Potential Problems Arising from Inaccurate Footprints:

• Alignment Issues: Incorrectly sized or oriented footprints can lead to components not aligning with their intended pads, making assembly problematic.
• Soldering Challenges: A mismatch between component size and pad dimensions can result in poor solder joints, insufficient solder coverage, or solder bridging.
• Functionality Breakdown: Components placed inaccurately may not function as intended, leading to circuit malfunctions or complete board failure.
• Thermal Issues: Inaccurate footprints can affect thermal performance, potentially causing overheating or reducing component lifespan.
• Increased Rejection Rate: Boards with footprint inaccuracies may not meet quality standards, leading to higher rejection rates during production checks.
• Component Interference: Overlapping or closely packed components due to inaccurate footprints can lead to physical interference during assembly.

Component Clearances

• Placing components too closely together can create solder bridging, resulting in short circuits, performance degradation, and PCB failure. In PCB design, the arrangement of components on the board’s surface is a critical aspect that directly affects the overall functionality and reliability of the electronic device. Component placement refers to the strategic positioning of components, such as integrated circuits (ICs), resistors, capacitors, and connectors on the PCB. When components are placed too closely together, several issues can arise, most notably solder bridging, which can have significant implications for the PCB’s performance:
  • Solder Bridging: Solder bridging occurs when the solder connecting adjacent pads of components melts during the soldering process and forms an unintended connection or bridge between the two pads. This connection can create a short circuit, allowing current to flow where it shouldn’t and potentially causing malfunction or damage to the circuit. Solder bridging often leads to erratic behavior, incorrect functionality, or complete failure of the device.
  • Short Circuits: Solder bridging essentially creates a conductive pathway between components that should be isolated. This can disrupt the intended flow of signals and power, leading to short circuits. Short circuits can cause overheating, increased power consumption, and even permanent damage to components, further reducing the device’s lifespan.

• To prevent these issues, PCB designers need to carefully plan component placement to minimize PCB failure by considering factors such as:

  • Minimum Clearance: Each component has specific requirements for minimum clearance, which ensures enough space between components to prevent solder bridging. Design guidelines provided by component manufacturers and industry standards are crucial in determining these clearances.
  • Thermal Considerations: Components generate heat during operation, and placing them too closely together can lead to heat buildup. Adequate spacing helps dissipate heat and prevent thermal issues that could affect the device’s performance and lifespan.
  • Reliability Issues: PCBs are often used in applications where reliability is paramount, such as aerospace, medical devices, or industrial control systems. Solder bridging increases the likelihood of unexpected failures, which can be disastrous in critical applications. Ensuring proper component spacing is essential for maintaining the reliability and longevity of the device.
  • Signal Integrity: Components placed too closely together might interfere with signal paths, leading to cross-talk and electromagnetic interference. Proper spacing maintains signal integrity and reduces the risk of signal-related problems.
  • Performance Degradation: Even if a solder bridge doesn’t lead to an immediate short circuit, it can still impact the circuit’s performance. Unintended connections can interfere with signal paths, affecting the integrity of the signals and leading to data errors or reduced signal quality. This degradation can compromise the device’s overall performance, leading to inaccurate readings, slower response times, or reduced data transfer rates.

Neglecting Thermal Relief

Inadequate Use of Thermal Relief Pads Causing PCB Failure

• Soldering Difficulties: Without appropriate thermal relief pads, the solder might not flow correctly. This uneven distribution can lead to weak or incomplete solder joints.
• Assembly Challenges: The assembly process becomes less predictable, with a higher likelihood of solder-related defects, when thermal relief pads aren’t used correctly.
• Increased Errors: Lack of proper thermal relief can escalate the frequency of soldering errors, requiring rework or leading to failed components.

Heat Management Oversights

• Heat Accumulation: Placing heat-generating components near the edges can cause localized areas of high temperature. This concentration can lead to reduced efficiency in heat dissipation.
• System Performance Issues: As heat builds up, components might operate outside their optimal temperature ranges, which can degrade their performance and reduce their lifespan.
• Potential for Component Damage: Prolonged exposure to elevated temperatures can damage sensitive components or affect their reliability.

Misalignment of Surface Mount Devices (SMDs)

• Wave Soldering Issues: If SMDs are not oriented correctly concerning the direction of wave soldering, solder might not cover the intended pads fully, or it may bridge between pads unintentionally and cause PCB failure.
• Short or Open Connections: Incorrect alignment increases the risk of creating short circuits between pads or failing to establish necessary connections.
• Rework and Quality Control: Misaligned SMDs can lead to increased time in reworking boards and more rigorous quality control checks to catch and correct errors.

Routing Errors Leading to PCB Failure

Routing is a critical phase in PCB design, and errors in this phase can lead to catastrophes. Here are prevalent routing-related mistakes that can cause PCB failure:

Inaccurate Trace Widths

• Incorrect trace widths can lead to heat buildup, affecting overall system reliability. Ensuring proper trace width adherence is vital. In a printed circuit board (PCB), traces are the conductive pathways that carry electrical signals between components. The width of these traces, commonly called trace width or trace thickness, plays a significant role in determining how effectively electrical current can flow through them. The choice of trace width has implications for a PCB design’s electrical and thermal aspects.

Electrical Considerations

• The width of a trace affects its electrical resistance. Narrower traces have higher resistance, which can lead to voltage drops and signal degradation. Conversely, wider traces have lower resistance and provide a smoother path for the current to flow. Maintaining appropriate trace widths is crucial to ensure the proper functioning of the circuit and to prevent electrical issues such as:

  • Voltage Drop: Voltage drop occurs when current flows through a trace with higher resistance. This can lead to a discrepancy between the voltage supplied and the voltage received by the component, potentially affecting its performance or causing it to malfunction.
  • Signal Attenuation: Narrow traces can introduce signal attenuation, especially for high-frequency signals. This attenuation reduces the signal’s amplitude and quality, leading to data errors or unreliable communication between components.
  • Thermal Considerations: Apart from their electrical characteristics, traces also play a role in dissipating heat generated by components on the PCB. Components such as ICs, power regulators, and other active devices produce heat during operation. If traces are too narrow to carry away this heat efficiently, it can lead to localized heat buildup, which has several negative consequences:
  • Overheating Components: Insufficiently sized traces may struggle to dissipate the heat generated by components, causing them to heat up beyond acceptable limits. Overheated components can experience reduced performance, accelerated wear, and premature failure.
  • Thermal Stress: Inadequate heat dissipation can lead to thermal stress in the PCB material, causing expansion and contraction. This can result in mechanical pressure on solder joints, components, and the PCB itself, potentially leading to solder joint cracks, delamination, and other reliability issues.
  • Temperature-Dependent Behavior: Many electronic components exhibit different behaviors at varying temperatures. If heat buildup causes localized hotspots on the PCB, components operating within those areas may behave unpredictably or exhibit reduced lifespans.
  • Ensuring Proper Trace Width Adherence: Adhering to trace width guidelines is vital to avoid these issues and maintain a reliable and efficient PCB design. Designers consider various factors when determining trace width, including the current-carrying capacity of the trace, the required electrical performance, and the desired thermal management. Industry standards, design guidelines provided by PCB software tools, and component datasheets offer valuable insights into appropriate trace widths for different current levels and applications. Designers should also consider the layer stackup, copper weight, and overall thermal strategy when deciding on trace widths to prevent PCB failure.

Proximity-Induced Connections

Proximity-induced connections are a concern in PCB layouts and can often cause PCB failures. When traces are positioned closely without suitable insulation, various issues arise.

• Issues with Close-Proximity Traces:
  • Unintended Connections: Traces that come too close might inadvertently connect.
  • Short Circuits: These accidental connections can cause direct shorts, leading to malfunction.
  • System Instability: A PCB’s reliability can be compromised, resulting in unpredictable behavior.
  • PCB Design Solutions:
  • Optimized Trace Layouts: Prioritize layouts that ensure safe distances between traces.
  • Enhanced Insulation: Use high-quality insulating materials between traces to prevent accidental connections.
  • Learn about our PCB design solutions for optimized trace layouts.

Right Angle Traces and Board Edge Clearance Issues

Right-angle traces near the edges of a PCB can present challenges. Insufficient clearance can lead to a host of problems affecting both signal integrity and overall performance.

• Problems with Right-Angle Traces and Inadequate Clearance:
  • Shorts: Traces close to the edge can accidentally connect to the board’s edge or adjacent components, leading to short circuits and causing PCB failure.
  • Signal Integrity Compromised: Proper trace paths are essential for maintaining signal clarity. Right-angle traces, or acid traps, near the edge, can distort or reflect signals.
  • Performance Degradation: A compromised signal can reduce the efficiency and speed of the system.
  • Solutions and Best Practices:
    • Increase Clearance: Ensure adequate space between the traces and the board’s edges.
    • Avoid Right-Angle Turns: Opt for 45-degree or curved traces, which can mitigate reflection and distortion.
    • Routine Testing: Conduct regular signal integrity tests to identify and rectify potential issues.
    • Use PCB Design Software: Employ advanced design tools that flag potential clearance or right-angle issues before fabrication.

Suboptimal Routing Strategies Can Cause PCB Failure

PCB design often faces the challenge of optimal trace routing. Suboptimal routing strategies can introduce several complications, including connectivity issues, signal interference, and deviations from design specifications.

• Drawbacks of Inefficient Routing Strategies:
  • Connectivity Issues: Poorly planned routing can cause missed connections or create unintentional connections between traces.
  • Signal Interference: Overlapping or closely spaced traces may lead to crosstalk or electromagnetic interference, affecting signal quality.
  • Non-Compliance with Design Specifications: Failing to adhere to prescribed design specifications can result in production rejections or systems not performing to expected standards.
  • Solutions and Best Practices:
  • Utilize PCB Design Software: Modern design software provides routing assistance, helping designers avoid potential pitfalls that can cause PCB failure.
  • Plan Layer Stack-Up: Strategically plan trace routes across different layers to minimize interference and improve connectivity.
  • Prioritize Key Signals: Identify and prioritize critical signal routes, ensuring they have the most direct and interference-free paths.
  • Regular Reviews: Periodically review and refine routing strategies to accommodate evolving design needs and to identify potential problem areas.

Incorporating Best Practices for Via Design and Management

Vias play a critical role in multilayer PCB designs, allowing electrical connections between different layers of the board. However, improper via design and placement can lead to numerous issues that may cause PCB failure. Below, we’ll explore common via-related mistakes and provide insights on how to manage them effectively.

• Via Size and Placement: Vias that are either too large or too small for their intended purpose can present issues. Oversized vias can waste valuable board real estate, while undersized vias might not be able to handle the current levels or dissipate heat adequately. It’s crucial to adjust via sizes based on their purpose and current-carrying requirements.
• Via Stubs: A via stub occurs when a via doesn’t go through all the layers but stops part-way. This can cause signal reflection at high frequencies, leading to signal integrity issues. Designers should aim to minimize or eliminate via stubs, especially in high-speed designs.
• Thermal Issues with Vias: Vias can both dissipate and generate heat. When routing high current paths through vias, it’s essential to ensure the via can handle the thermal requirements. On the flip side, vias can be used strategically to pull heat away from components and help manage thermal hotspots on the PCB.
• Tenting and Masking: Tenting refers to covering vias with solder mask to prevent solder or contaminants from entering. In contrast, open vias are exposed and can get filled with solder during the assembly process, which might not always be desirable. Deciding when to tent or leave vias open depends on the specific requirements of the PCB and its intended application.
• Via-to-Trace and Via-to-Via Spacing: Adequate spacing between vias and traces and between multiple vias is essential to prevent short circuits, ensure reliable soldering, and maintain signal integrity.

Tips for Effective Via Management:

• Use Via Calculators: Many PCB design tools come with via calculators that help determine the appropriate size and thermal handling capacity of vias based on current levels.
• Adopt Blind and Buried Vias for Compact Designs: For designs where board space is at a premium, consider using blind or buried vias. These vias only span certain layers of the PCB, allowing for a more compact design while still ensuring the necessary electrical connections.
• Stay Updated with Manufacturing Capabilities: Not all vias can be reliably manufactured by all PCB fabrication houses. It’s crucial to maintain communication with your PCB manufacturer to understand their capabilities and limitations related to via design and production.

By focusing on these best practices, designers can ensure their PCBs are robust, reliable, free from common via-related pitfalls, and avoid PCB failure.

Preventing Common PCB Design Mistakes That Can Cause PCB Failure

To ensure a successful PCB design, taking proactive steps and learning from past mistakes is crucial. Here’s how you can avoid the common pitfalls:

Consider Design for Manufacturability (DFM)

• Anticipating Mistakes: By integrating DFM (Design for Manufacturability) principles early in the design phase, potential pitfalls and common errors can be foreseen and avoided. This proactive approach can save both time and costs in the long run.
• Layout Considerations: It’s crucial for designers to carefully plan the PCB layout, ensuring components are appropriately spaced, traces are routed optimally, and high-heat areas are effectively managed.
• Component Footprints: Accurate design of component footprints is paramount. Incorrect or imprecise footprints can lead to alignment issues, soldering challenges, and potential functionality problems in the final assembly.
• Manufacturing Processes: Understanding the manufacturing process is vital to avoid common causes of PCB failure. This includes being aware of the capabilities and limitations of assembly machinery, soldering techniques, and testing procedures. By designing with these in mind, a smoother transition from design to production is achieved.
• Read about the importance of Design for Manufacturability in PCB Design.

Thermal Management Strategies

• Heat-Related Challenges: Without effective thermal management, PCBs can experience heat buildup, leading to potential damage, decreased component lifespan, and impaired system performance.
• Component Placement: Positioning heat-generating components wisely can facilitate better heat dissipation. It’s advisable to avoid placing these components too close to each other or near the board’s edges, where heat dissipation might be limited.
• Thermal Vias: Incorporating thermal vias can help in transferring heat from the top layer of the PCB to the underlying layers, enhancing heat distribution and dissipation.
• Heat Sinks: Integrating heat sinks, especially with high-power components, can significantly improve heat dissipation, ensuring the components remain within their operational temperature range.
• Thermal Interface Materials (TIMs): TIMs, like thermal pads or pastes, enhance the thermal connection between components and heat sinks, further assisting in effective heat dissipation.
• Systematic Testing: Regular thermal testing, like infrared thermal imaging, can help identify hotspots early on, enabling designers to make necessary modifications before the final product is released.

Trace Width Calculations

• Importance of Correct Trace Width: The trace width in a PCB design directly influences its current-carrying capacity. An inadequate trace width for the given current can result in overheating and cause PCB failure.
• Factors Affecting Trace Width:
  • Current Load: It’s essential to accurately gauge the amount of current a trace will carry to determine its optimal width.
  • Material Properties: Different PCB materials have varied conductivity levels, which impacts the trace width required for a specific current load.
  • Temperature Rise: Considering the acceptable temperature rise is crucial as excessive heating can affect the PCB’s lifespan and functionality.
• Trace Width Calculators: Leveraging tools and calculators specifically designed to determine optimal trace widths based on the given parameters can be instrumental in achieving accurate results.
• Benefits of Proper Trace Width:
  • Prevention of Overheating: Ensuring that the traces can handle the current without excessive heat buildup is vital for circuit reliability.
  • Avoidance of Electrical Failures: Correct trace width minimizes the risk of electrical shorts and potential component failures, ensuring a long-lasting and stable PCB design.
• Regular Reviews: As part of the design process, periodic reviews and checks of trace width calculations against real-world performance can offer insights into potential areas of improvement.

Comprehensive Testing

• Significance of Multi-stage Testing: Implementing tests at different design phases helps in the early detection of flaws, ensuring a smoother transition to production without costly reworks due to causes of PCB failure.
• Phases of Design Testing:
  • Conceptual Phase: Preliminary tests during the initial design phase can help in identifying major flaws or impracticalities.
  • Design Iteration: After making adjustments based on initial feedback, repeated testing ensures the modifications are effective.
  • Pre-production: Before heading into full-scale production, it’s essential to test the final design to verify its robustness and reliability.
• Types of Tests:
  • Functional Tests: Assess if the circuit performs its intended function without errors.
  • Stress Tests: Expose the design to extreme conditions to ensure it can withstand unusual scenarios.
  • Compatibility Tests: Ensure that the design works seamlessly with other components or systems it will interact with.
• Advantages of Rigorous Testing:
  • Cost Savings: Identifying and addressing issues before production can save significant costs associated with reworks and recalls.
  • Enhanced Reliability: A thoroughly tested PCB design is more likely to have a longer operational life and fewer failures.
  • Reputation Protection: Delivering a robust and reliable product to the market enhances a company’s reputation and customer trust.
• Feedback Loop: Incorporating feedback from each testing phase back into the design process ensures continuous improvement and refinement of the PCB design.

Addressing Soldering Issues in PCB Design

Soldering problems can be mitigated through careful design and manufacturing considerations:

Correct Footprint Design

• Ensure accurate component footprints to prevent misalignment and soldering defects during assembly. Component footprints in PCB design refer to the precise layouts and dimensions that depict where and how each electronic component will be soldered onto the PCB. These footprints provide crucial information to the PCB designer and the manufacturer about correctly placing, aligning, and soldering components onto the board during assembly.

• Importance of Accurate Component Footprints:

  • Proper Alignment: Accurate footprints ensure that components are aligned correctly with the designated solder pads and copper traces on the PCB. Misalignment can lead to electrical connectivity issues, mechanical stress on parts, difficulty fitting the PCB into its intended enclosure, and cause PCB failure.
  • Soldering Quality: Accurate footprints help ensure that solder joints form correctly between the component leads and the PCB pads. When the alignment is correct, the solder can flow evenly, creating robust and reliable solder joints. Misaligned parts can result in solder bridges, cold solder joints, or incomplete solder connections, which can cause electrical discontinuities and reduce the reliability of the PCB.

• Best Practices for Ensuring Accurate Footprints:

  • Consult Datasheets:
    • Component datasheets often include recommended footprint dimensions and layouts. Designers should refer to these datasheets to ensure the footprints match the manufacturer’s recommendations.
  • Use Design Software Libraries:
    • Most PCB design software includes libraries of pre-defined component footprints. Using these libraries helps ensure the footprints are accurate and compatible with industry standards.
  • Double-Check Dimensions:
    • Designers should verify the dimensions of each pad, lead, and mounting hole in the footprint against the component’s datasheet. Minor discrepancies can lead to significant alignment issues during assembly.
  • Perform Test Fits:
    • Before finalizing the design, performing Test fits using prototypes or simulation tools is a good practice. This helps identify potential alignment or soldering issues early in the design phase.
  • Preventing Shorts and Opens:
    • Misaligned or incorrect footprints can lead to solder bridges between adjacent pads or open connections where no solder joint forms. Both situations can cause shorts or opens in the circuit, leading to functional failures or intermittent behavior.
  • Ease of Manufacturing:
    • Manufacturers use accurate component footprints as a reference during the assembly process. When footprints are precise, manufacturers can automate the assembly process more effectively, reducing the risk of errors and minimizing the need for manual adjustments.
  • Thermal Relief Pads:

    • Implement thermal relief pads for components with large ground connections to facilitate proper soldering and avoid connectivity issues.

  • Optimal Solder Mask Application

    • Apply solder mask with precision to prevent solder bridges and ensure proper component isolation.

  • Reflow Soldering Considerations

    • Understand reflow soldering profiles and component compatibility to prevent overheating and ensure reliable solder joints.

Fixing Common Causes of PCB Failure

In the unfortunate event of a PCB failure, swift action is imperative. Here’s how 911EDA can help:

• Rapid Response: At 911EDA, we understand the urgency and respond quickly to PCB failure incidents.
• Thorough Testing: We conduct extensive examinations to determine the primary reasons behind failures.
• Design Review: Our specialized team scrutinizes your design to highlight and address the design inadequacies causing the malfunction.
• Precision Corrections: Upon identifying the issue, our seasoned engineers and designers implement the required adjustments to ensure your board operates optimally.
• Experienced Team: Our professionals at 911EDA bring years of expertise in PCB troubleshooting, ensuring effective solutions.
• Follow-up Support: Post-correction, we offer support to ensure your PCB consistently delivers peak performance.
• Documentation Update: Along with the fixes, we update all related documentation to reflect the changes, ensuring a seamless transition for future productions.

Connect with Us

If you face issues like these, tell us about your PCB failures, and we will contact you to discuss them.

Got Questions? Our FAQs Have Answers

Curious about the nitty-gritty of PCB design services? You can explore our frequently asked questions section to find answers to common queries. From design strategies to turnaround times, our FAQs provide insights into what sets 911EDA’s services apart.

Conclusion: Navigating the Design Landscape

In the intricate world of PCB design, the path to success is lined with awareness and continuous improvement. Steering clear of common PCB design mistakes empowers engineers and designers to create robust, efficient, and reliable electronic products that define our technological landscape.

Remember, understanding the nuances of PCB design is an ongoing journey, and by avoiding these pitfalls, you’re one step closer to achieving excellence in your creations.